The Unitarian Universalist Association will end the fiscal year on June 30 with an unexpected $1.3 million deficit. The Board of Trustees met with the UUA administration this afternoon, June 24, to ask how they had all been taken by surprise by a drop in revenue from major gifts to the UUA’s $24 million operating budget. The administration agreed to submit a revised budget with lower revenue projections for the new fiscal year by August 1, and said it was reviewing staff procedures to understand what had gone wrong.
On June 18, President Peter Morales alerted the board’s executive committee that the UUA had failed to raise approximately $1.5 million of $2.4 million it had projected as revenue from unrestricted major gifts. On June 20—last Friday—he notified the full board about the deficit. He also sent a memo to staff that day informing them that the Rev. Terry Sweetser, vice president of Stewardship and Development, had told senior staff about the shortfall earlier in the week.
“This was a shock to me, a shock to us, and clearly a shock to the board,” Morales told the trustees during their pre-General Assembly meeting in Providence, R.I. “In retrospect I should have seen some things coming, and responded to early indicators.”
Tim Brennan, treasurer and chief financial officer, presented updated figures to the board, identifying a $1.2 million shortfall in major gifts. The total deficit is $1.353 million.
Morales and Brennan told the board that the UUA would spend the next month examining staff procedures and preparing a modified budget for the 2015 fiscal year, which begins July 1.
(In March, Sweetser announced his plans to step down at the end of GA from his role as head of Stewardship and Development.)
The board’s Finance Committee chair, the Rev. Sarah Stewart, responded to the administration’s presentation by telling her colleagues, “We need to be in an accountable relationship, but not an adversarial relationship.”
Stewart said the executive committee had asked Morales “for an action plan to fix systemic problems so the board can be confident in the budget.” She proposed having trustees examine income projections for each proposed budget three months prior to voting on the full budget. The board currently reviews and approves the budget each April.
Financial Adviser Larry Ladd did challenge Morales: “The president needs to be the chief fundraiser. That should be an expectation of the board.”
“Major donors give more and feel more obligated to give if they’re engaged with the CEO,” Ladd added.
The Rev. Rob Eller Isaacs, a trustee, said the practice of budgeting unsecured major gifts in the operating budget “needs to stop.” “Relying on major donors to balance the budget is a very old, time-honored tradition among us,” he said, but “it represents a cultural motif that we are attempting to overturn.”
Delegates will hear more about the UUA’s finances during General Session presentations on Friday morning and in a budget hearing immediately afterward.
New metrics draw praise
In other business Tuesday, trustees refined a set of principles they will introduce to delegates and use in reimagining General Assembly. Trustees also reviewed a report about how the UUA responds to allegations of misconduct by religious professionals in congregations, which Moderator Jim Key and other trustees will present on Friday.
And trustees responded enthusiastically to a presentation by the administration on its metrics—a topic that has generated tense conversation in past years. The Rev. Dr. Terasa Cooley, the UUA’s program and strategy officer, introduced a Congregational Self-Assessment Tool the UUA has developed. Congregations will find the tool useful to themselves, she said, while giving the UUA insight into the data it collects from them. (The Congregational Self-Assessment Tool is included in the written report the administration submitted, beginning on page 21.)
The Rev. Harlan Limpert, chief operating officer, thanked Policy Governance consultant Eric Craymer for the work he has done with the board and administration to develop a meaningful and useful approach to metrics. Moderator Key moved that the board accept the report “with gratitude,” which they did.
The board will complete its pre-GA meeting Wednesday morning, after which two trustees— Natalia Averett and the Rev. Clyde Grubbs—will complete their terms. Two newly elected trustees will join the board on Monday, June 30, after the conclusion of this week’s GA.